Wildomar's view of the power lines

Wildomar's view of the power lines
Segment of the proposed Talega-Escondido/Valley-Serrano Interconnect

Saturday, March 30, 2019

2019, LEAPS, Nevada Hydro, Talega-Escondido/Valley-Serrano Transmission line. It's all back

It will surprise some citizens of the Elsinore Valley that LEAPS, the Lake Elsinore Advanced Pumped Storage project, has returned. An application for LEAPS was filed in 2017. I've been watching some developments over 2018. By November 2018, LEAPS had presenters wooing community organizations. Since my first post here in seven years is meant only to establish that LEAPS is back, here's a link to the LEAPS website:

http://leapshydro.com/

At the LEAPS Hydro site,you'll find general information on what LEAPS offers the community. Some highlights are that LEAPS will buy 15,000 acre feet of water to put into Lake Elsinore and continue to add water to account for evaporation to keep the lake surface somewhere between 1240 and 1246 feet above sea level. I think the range at which they maintain the lake level will be determined by the vertical size of their intake/outflow structure, and I'd be more specific about this structure, but the LEAPS proponents haven't provide any specifications on the structure, only to say it minimally disturbs the lake and is under some review with the Lake Elsinore San Jacinto Watershed Authority (LESJWA). -- Also, LEAPS has been wooing LESJWA.

A second development is that the upper reservoir, which will contain approximately 5000-6000 acre feet of the 15,000 mentioned above, is now to be in Decker Canyon instead of Morrell Canyon.

Unchanged from the original plan is that LEAPS includes and depends on 30 miles of new overhead transmission lines through the National Forest.

The business model for LEAPS has changed. In the past, Nevada Hydro proposed to build the plant, transfer it to the California Independent System Operators (CAISO), while they own the transmission line.

The new business model will take some time to study and explain, but in short, is best explained by this passage from a 3/13/2019 letter from Nevada Hydro to CAISO:

Q: What is the projected cost of the LEAPS project and its forecasted annual revenue requirement?
A. Nevada Hydro currently estimates the project’s total cost to be approximately $2 billion...[assuming] a 50-year project life, a 50%/50% debt-to-equity ratio, 5.0% debt rate, 11% nominal return on equity (“ROE”), 29.65 %  state and federal taxes, 1.85% inflation and 0.1% G&A, the resulting levelized real revenue requirement is estimated at $177 million annually.
Get that? Nevada Hydro will operate the plant and transmission lines for the public benefit and require only $177 per million annually from the California rate payer. This is impressively close to the number that FERC estimated LEAPS would lose yearly, after adjusting for 2019 dollars:
Cost table from FERC Final Environmental Impact Statement 2007.
I adjusted the total yearly lose which was estimated in 2005 dollars to 2019 dollars.

And, they could succeed with this business model because a few factors help them argue that the transmission line plus LEAPS acts as infrastructure therefore the public should pay for it and in the 50-year life span it may save money for rate payers in San Diego and Orange counties. It may also assist California in meeting its ambitious greenhouse gas emissions cuts.

I'll elaborate more on what is in the letter for LEAPS Hydro to CAISO, as it answers two of three major unanswered questions I have about the new LEAPS/LINES project. But for now, here are some diagrams I've assembled illustrating the project. Some are mine, and some are from the LEAPS Hydro Facebook page:

This map is from the LEAPS Hydro Facebook page. It shows the current proposal for a Decker Canyon reservoir, buried and surface transmission lines, penstock, power house location and intake/outflow structure.

Here's an overview of LEAPS that leaves out the enthusiastic interpretations (which you can get from LEAPS Hydro):


Diagram summarizing some qualities and impact of LEAPS/LINES project


It can be argued that the net benefits to the San Diego electricity service area outweighs the impacts to local residents, especially as viewed by the beneficiaries. The LEAPS transmission line is an essential part of the project. It will provide the only 500 kilovolt major artery to the northwestern service area of San Diego Gas & Electric. Below is a map showing southern California's electricity service provider areas and transmission lines colored by their capacity. It shows clearly how LEAPS/LINES extends the major power grid into SDG&E territory.  

Add caption


I've also added a closer view of our area.



jg




Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Fire Collection

Below is a collection of images of recent fires along the escarpment on the west end of our valley, part of which is the route for the proposed Talega-Escondido/Valley-Serrano Interconnect:


My hypothesis is that 200-foot transmission towers would have impeded control of these fires, and therefore placing the towers on this escarpment creates a great risk to fire fighters, nearby residents, and natural resources.

jg


Sunday, March 20, 2011

Documentation for LEAPS and TE/VS Interconnect

The California Public Utilities Commission has scheduled public scoping meetings
for the Lake Elsinore Advanced Pump Storage Project and the Talega Escondido /
Valley Serrano transmission lines on April 5, 2011 Lake Elsinore Ortega High
School on Chaney St. from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. Then again at the Murrieta Community Center on April 6, 2011 from 3 p.m. to 5 p.m. Documents pertaining to the Notice of Preparation Hearings scheduled for can be found here:

http://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/published/proceedings/A1007001.htm

jg

Saturday, March 19, 2011

Notice of Preparation not available

To All Concerned,
        The NOP states that documents for reviewed related to the upcoming meeting are available at this site  Lake Elsinore Branch Library 600 West Graham Avenue, Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
 (951)674‐4517.  I just visited this site and could not find any documents related to the current application which is the subject of the upcoming meeting.  The library does have documents on LEAPS dated 2001 but no current documents.  If you are concerned about the availability of these documents you can complain to By Electronic Mail to: please remember to include your name and return address in the e‐mail message. E‐mail messages should be sent to:         interconnect@aspeneg.com
John

Update: message sent to Apen Environmental regarding the failure to make current LEAPS documents available:
March 19 2011
To Aspen Environmental,
        The NOP for Talega‐Escondido/Valley‐Serrano 500 kV Interconnect Project Application A.10‐07‐001 states that documents for reviewed related to the upcoming meeting are available at this site  Lake Elsinore Branch Library 600 West Graham Avenue, Lake Elsinore, CA 92530 (951)674‐4517.  I just visited this site and could not find any documents related to the current application which is the subject of the upcoming meeting.  In the interest of justice and informed decision making I request a postponement of the April 5, 6 2011 meeting until one month after these documents are available for public access.
John

Feel free to follow John's lead and send a similar request.

EVMWD Sky View Pump Station

To those concerned,
     The EVMWD sky view pump station serving Rancho Capistrano and surrounding areas on the Ortega mountains is currently inadequate for fire prevention.  The system requires on-site emergency electrical generation, increased water storage and additional access.  The transmission lines increases these risks along the entire transmission line corridor.  These risks are not addressed or mitigated in TNHC's CPUC PEA.  During a candidates meeting I attended last year, Ron Young, (EVMWD GM) declared water storage for fire prevention as the primary responsibility of EVMWD.  This is a topic for discussion for the upcoming meeting.
Sincerely,
John

Friday, March 18, 2011

LEAPS all over again

The LEAPS project and it's associated transmission lines have returned. A copy of the Notice of Preparation is available on http://www.stopleaps.info/.

It is necessary for the public to be aware of these projects' impacts in order to assess the benefits.

I welcome discussion on this issue, and though the title of this blog reflects my position that I oppose these projects, I will post differing viewpoints as guest postings and in comments.

Regarding guest postings and moderation of comments, I reserve the option to adapt the comment policy as needed based on the level of civility and honesty through which contributors express themselves. By civility, criticism must be aimed at the project and the issues and not be personal attacks or use language considered unpublishable. By honesty, commenters should be stakeholders (in the project or community) and they should be presenting themselves as a single entity, and only as that entity. Comments will be moderated, but as a show a good faith, I'll allow comments to be posted anonymously.

jg